As the 2025 NFL season unfolds, Pittsburgh Steelers head coach Mike Tomlin faces a pivotal moment in his tenure. With a young, talented roster bolstered by offseason additions and the continued development of key players, the pressure is on to deliver playoff success. However, two significant pitfalls loom large, and avoiding them will be crucial for the Steelers’ campaign.
Mistake 1: Mismanaging Quarterback Development
One of the defining factors of the Steelers’ success will be the development and management of quarterback Kenny Pickett. Now entering his third season, Pickett has shown flashes of brilliance but remains inconsistent in high-pressure situations. Tomlin must ensure Pickett is given the right tools, schemes, and support to elevate his play.
This starts with tailoring the offensive system to Pickett’s strengths. Offensive coordinator Matt Canada, often criticized for predictable play-calling, will need to adopt a more creative approach. The Steelers have invested heavily in their receiving corps, including standout wide receiver George Pickens and veteran Diontae Johnson, alongside promising rookie tight end Darnell Washington. Leveraging these weapons with dynamic play designs is critical.
Equally important is protecting Pickett in the pocket. The Steelers addressed their offensive line woes by drafting lineman Broderick Jones and acquiring experienced free agents. However, if Tomlin and the coaching staff fail to establish cohesion and consistency in the line, Pickett’s development could stagnate under constant pressure.
History has shown that mishandling a young quarterback can set a franchise back years. Tomlin must avoid putting undue pressure on Pickett by balancing offensive responsibility with a strong running game, led by Najee Harris. By doing so, the Steelers can create an environment where their quarterback can thrive rather than falter.
Mistake 2: Neglecting Defensive Adjustments
The Steelers’ defense, long the hallmark of their identity, remains a formidable unit led by All-Pro edge rusher T.J. Watt and standout safety Minkah Fitzpatrick. However, a refusal to adapt to modern offensive trends could leave the unit exposed.
Tomlin, who has always emphasized a physical, aggressive defensive philosophy, must ensure his scheme evolves. The NFL is increasingly driven by high-octane passing attacks, with offenses utilizing motion, spread formations, and quick decision-making to exploit weaknesses. The Steelers’ defense, while talented, struggled at times in 2024 to contain elite quarterbacks who could dissect their secondary.
The addition of rookie cornerback Joey Porter Jr. provides a boost, but Tomlin must ensure the unit operates cohesively. A heavy reliance on man-to-man coverage without adequate safety support could be costly against teams with deep receiving corps. Additionally, addressing communication lapses and shoring up run defense will be critical in maintaining balance.
In-game adjustments are equally important. Tomlin’s reputation as a “player’s coach” is well-earned, but he has faced criticism for being slow to adapt during games. This season, he must make real-time defensive adjustments to counter high-powered offenses.
A Season of Opportunity and Pressure
Mike Tomlin’s ability to avoid these costly mistakes will define the Steelers’ 2025 season. With a talented roster and a mix of seasoned veterans and emerging stars, the team has the potential to contend in a competitive AFC. For Tomlin, the challenge lies in navigating these pitfalls while maximizing the team’s strengths. Success could cement his legacy as one of the NFL’s elite coaches, while failure may raise questions about the team’s long-term direction.