Kenny Pickett’s transition from the Philadelphia Eagles to the Cleveland Browns has been under intense scrutiny during the team’s Organized Team Activities (OTAs). Initially viewed as a potential frontrunner for the starting quarterback position, recent performances have raised questions about his readiness for the role.
Early Expectations and Current Performance
At the onset of OTAs, Pickett was given the first-team snaps, signaling the Browns’ initial confidence in his abilities. However, reports from recent sessions indicate that he has struggled to distinguish himself from the competition. In team drills, Pickett completed 9 of 16 passes, failing to record a touchdown or an interception. In contrast, veteran Joe Flacco completed 9 of 14 passes with one touchdown, and rookie Dillon Gabriel achieved 11 completions on 16 attempts, throwing two touchdowns and one interception .
Rising Competition
The Browns’ quarterback room is crowded, with Flacco, Gabriel, and rookie Shedeur Sanders also vying for the starting spot. Sanders, in particular, has garnered attention for his performance, completing multiple touchdowns during red zone drills and showcasing a strong command of the offense . This increased competition has intensified the pressure on Pickett to perform consistently.
Implications for the Browns
The Browns’ decision to trade for Pickett, sending Dorian Thompson-Robinson and a 2025 fifth-round pick to the Eagles, was made with the hope of solidifying the quarterback position. However, with Deshaun Watson’s availability uncertain due to injury, the team may need to reconsider its options if Pickett does not demonstrate significant improvement in the coming weeks .
Looking Ahead
As OTAs progress, the Browns’ coaching staff will closely evaluate Pickett’s performance. With the season opener against the Carolina Panthers on August 8, 2025, approaching, the competition for the starting quarterback role is expected to intensify . Pickett’s ability to rebound from these early setbacks will be crucial in determining his future with the team.