Houston Astros Re-Signing Justin Verlander Despite His Visible Decline During an Injury-Ridden 2024.

 

The Houston Astros’ decision to re-sign Justin Verlander after a rocky 2024 season may have raised eyebrows among fans and analysts, considering the veteran pitcher’s visible decline amid injury struggles. Verlander, who was a key part of the Astros’ pitching staff and their 2022 World Series title, appeared to be a shell of his former dominant self in 2024. Yet, despite the adversity he faced, the Astros opted to bring him back for the foreseeable future, signaling their continued faith in his ability and leadership.

 

### Injury Woes and Declining Performance

 

Verlander’s 2024 campaign was marred by multiple injuries that limited his effectiveness on the mound. The 41-year-old future Hall of Famer battled a number of physical setbacks, including arm discomfort and recurring issues with his mechanics. These struggles led to a significant dip in his velocity and command, two elements that had once made him one of the most feared pitchers in Major League Baseball.

 

Over the course of the season, Verlander posted an ERA over 4.50, his highest since 2014, and his strikeout rate, while still impressive, had noticeably dropped from previous years. His inability to maintain his elite form was evident, as his fastball averaged fewer than 94 mph, and his breaking pitches lacked the bite that once made him an unhittable force. As the season wore on, Verlander’s confidence seemed shaken, with the Astros having to adjust their pitching rotation to cover for his diminishing performance.

 

Despite these challenges, Verlander’s leadership and experience were invaluable to a young Astros team, which featured emerging stars like Framber Valdez, Cristian Javier, and Hunter Brown. While his raw stuff had slipped, Verlander remained a respected figure in the clubhouse, offering mentorship to younger pitchers and providing invaluable insight into how to approach high-pressure situations. His work ethic and commitment to rehabbing from injuries also continued to be a source of inspiration for his teammates.

 

### Astros’ Rationale for Re-Signing Verlander

 

Given Verlander’s age and injury concerns, many expected the Astros to part ways with him after the 2024 season. However, their decision to bring him back indicates a belief that Verlander can still contribute to their success, even if his best years are behind him. There are several reasons why the Astros opted to re-sign the aging ace.

 

First, the Astros are a team built on sustainability and consistency, and Verlander provides a steady presence in their rotation. While younger arms may provide more upside, Verlander’s experience in big games, including postseason play, cannot be overstated. His leadership and ability to perform under pressure—qualities that contributed to his historic career—are assets that cannot be easily replaced by a younger pitcher still trying to find his rhythm in MLB.

 

Second, the Astros’ pitching depth and finances make Verlander a more attractive option than other free agents. With a rotation that has been relatively stable in recent years, Houston doesn’t need to swing for the fences with a high-risk, high-reward pitcher. By re-signing Verlander, they maintain a solid veteran presence at the top of the rotation without having to overcommit resources to other unproven alternatives.

 

Lastly, the Astros may be betting that Verlander’s decline is not as steep as it appears. Injuries can often be the catalyst for a down year, and with proper rest and a focused offseason program, he could rebound in 2025. The Astros have shown confidence in their medical staff and their ability to bring players back from injury-related dips, making it reasonable to expect Verlander to return to at least a serviceable form.

 

### Conclusion

 

The Astros’ decision to re-sign Justin Verlander despite his struggles in 2024 might seem risky to some, but it reflects a deep understanding of the value he brings to the team both on and off the field. As he enters the twilight years of his career, Verlander’s presence remains vital to a Houston team that is focused on maintaining its winning culture and competing at the highest level. Whether he can return to his Cy Young form or remain a steady contributor will remain to be seen, but for now, the Astros are betting that the veteran still has enough in the tank to help them chase another title.